gulf911 wrote:Kim Crosser wrote: We already excuse any instructor who spends a session out with their student, but many of us work all day, teach, and still do a corner working session - it really isn't that bad, and it should be a learning experience.
Huh?? Since when do we excuse corner working for instructors that spend a session with their student?? I must have missed those events??..
Also, I don't know where you are corner working but you are not out there for 1 hr. its much closer to 2.
The vast majority does not like to corner work for many reasons, not one of those reasons include not wanting to help, or not wanting to volunteer. I have no problem helping setup and or tear down, loading the truck etc. I also enjoy instructing , but when asked what kind of incentives would help in getting more instructors to volunteer , and that small incentive doesn't cost the club a penny , its a win win in my book.
And I do believe Jackie asked the question and I gave an obvious answer, but don't ask me to stop asking because you don't like the answer.

We have ALWAYS attempted to excuse instructors who worked a session with their students. Very rarely, due to a (common) shortage of workers, we have asked someone to work two shifts, but this is an exceptionally rare occurrence. You still need to check in with us, but just tell us that you worked a session with your student (we don't always remember everybody, and we only check off the worker names) and you immediately go to the end of the candidate list.
I am not sure who said one hour - not I - however, the usual time out there is about 1 hour 10 minutes to 1 hour 20 minutes (6 corner working sessions, vs about 7/8 hours total time from 9am to 4pm/5pm = 1.16 to 1.33 hours).
My "puhleeze" comment is due to the following set of factors:
1. We did lots of surveying, analysis, etc. about using paid corner workers - turned out not feasible, and/or not enough people willing to pay a lot more for workers, and/or to lose driving time (for paid worker lunches, etc.). (See MANY long and exhaustive threads elsewhere on the whys and wherefores - search "paid corner workers".)
2. Especially in the West Lot, we usually need at least 10 corner workers per session (plus gate and start/finish = 12 people minimum). That means we need at least 72 corner workers to run an event. If we only have 90 people (as with many of the recent events), that is only 3 "extra" persons per run group (18/6). Some people are instructors who already worked a session, some have physical ailments that prevent corner working (so they work gate or s/f), and a LOT of people help with track setup, tech, AX operations all day, etc.
(When we have tried to shrink to 9 or 8 corners, we have wound up having to double-staff the ones that are covering too large an area, so fewer than 10 people out on the West lot courses doesn't seem to work.)
Unless some of the instructors want to bring their serfs to do their corner working for them, we just don't have enough people to be feasible to "excuse" instructors from corner working.
If we were willing to run all our events in the SE lot, with no more than 5-6 corners, then we could "excuse" many more people. As it is, we are frequently having to call for volunteers to fill in - especially in the Red and White run groups, where many of the instructors run.
That is why I asked that we "puhleeze" not go back down this path.
Ok - diatribe over - resume normal posting...
p.s.

Unless I note otherwise, the opinions in my posts reflect my personal views, and are not intended to be an official PCA-SDR position.